A broom stored on a truck’s trailer caused its brakes to lock on a rail crossing, with the driver jumping free just moments before a freight train smashed into it.
The Transport Accident Investigation Commission (TAIC) today released its final report into the crash, which happened in Waikanae on an early morning in October last year.
It found the driver should have called train control before crossing, which would have let controllers hold back the train. The driver didn’t call because a KiwiRail permit had wrongly told the trucking company for a decade the call wasn’t needed.
The Goodman Contractors truck was carrying an articulated dump truck to the company's yard about 100m past the tracks when its semi-trailer wheels locked as it turned off Main St. The engine stalled with the truck's front wheels in the middle of the tracks.
The driver tried to restart it. After 68 seconds the bells, lights and barriers activated, and one barrier arm came down on top of the cab. Twenty seconds later the driver saw the train and jumped from the cab five seconds before the 876-tonne freight train hit the truck at 68km/h.
No one was hurt, but the collision closed the crossing for hours and caused serious disruption to both traffic and train services.
Broom and brake hose

Investigators found a wooden broom stored at the front of the semi-trailer had pressed against the air brake hoses during the sharp turn. A reconstruction showed the hoses could push open the coupler’s quick-release lever and disconnect the air line. When that happens, the trailer’s brakes lock automatically.
After that, the truck could not move forwards or backwards, and the driver didn’t have time to find and fix the fault before the train arrived.
The truck and trailer had current certificates of fitness and no known faults. Goodmans has since fitted new couplers and connections across its fleet.
'No train control notification required'
The truck's 4.65m tall load was higher than the crossing's 4.5m safe height under the overhead power lines, so Goodmans required a KiwiRail permit to cross the tracks.
One condition, the main safety step for oversized loads, was that the driver or pilot vehicle call train control before crossing. This allows train controllers to either hold trains at a red signal to keep the crossing clear or tell the driver to wait for the train to pass.
TAIC found it was "virtually certain" the crash could have been avoided had the permit conditions been followed.
But from 2014, KiwiRail permits for Goodmans carried a note saying: "No train control notification required for any load 4.8m and under."
The note was tied to a proposed trial for over-height loads in the Wellington electrified area. An agreement was never signed, and the commission said even if it had, nothing in it would have removed the requirement to call train control.
Six-monthly renewals of the permit retained the note until May 2024, when KiwiRail changed the wording, but did not tell Goodmans that calls to train control were required again.
The commission said Goodmans was “very likely” still under the impression it didn’t need to call, with Goodmans telling investigators it could find no paperwork about the trial.
“We believe it was all forgotten about because there were no issues raised and perhaps due to personnel change,” the company said.
TAIC said KiwiRail helpdesk staff approved permit applications as an administrative task, with no safety check by operational staff and no monitoring of whether operators followed the conditions.
The crossing also had no system to warn train control it was blocked, and no sign showing the train control emergency number. TAIC said several people watched the crash unfold.

KiwiRail chief infrastructure officer Siva Sivapakkiam said the brakes activating unexpectedly had caused the truck to stop on the crossing.
“It highlights the need to take care around level crossings, watching for trains because being big, and heavy they take a long time to stop,” he said.
“KiwiRail has improved its permit system: clarified how they work to ensure there are no misunderstandings, and that permits are assessed appropriately.”
KiwiRail told TAIC all exemptions and memorandums of understanding had been rescinded. Sivapakkiam said KiwiRail would review what crossing-monitoring technology was available and whether other railways had solutions that could work here.
“We will also act on the recommendation to work with NZTA and the New Zealand Heavy Haulage Association to reinforce to heavy haulage operators their obligations when moving over-dimension loads across level crossings.”
NZTA told TAIC it would meet KiwiRail by November 25 to check whether any other operators were working under similar old arrangements. The Heavy Haulage Association said it knew of none.
The Elizabeth St crossing is the only direct road link between Waikanae’s town centre and the east of the town. About 7500 vehicles use it every day, along with about 80 passenger trains and 16 freight trains on a typical weekday.




















SHARE ME